our country’s most powerful media organizations now simply don’t care how
utterly one-sided their political coverage is.
appears to be the case with how the media has treated the accusations of Tara
Reade, who has accused Joe Biden, a former senator and vice president, of
sexual harassment and sexual assault.
treatment is of a piece with how (little) the media scrutinized sexual assault
allegations last year against Virginia Lt. Gov. Justin Fairfax.
accuses Biden of sexually assaulting her in 1993, when she worked in his Senate
office. Several people have said that Reade told them of the
Delaware Democrat’s alleged behavior at the time.
early last year, Reade had been vocal about her allegations that Biden treated and
touched her inappropriately. Then, on a March 25 podcast, she accused him of sexual
little of this story broke into legacy media coverage for nearly a month.
of the coverage by FiveThirtyEight shows that the story got
almost no interest from prominent networks and really received considerable
attention only on conservative-leaning websites.
The most that The New York Times editorial board could come
up with, while being inconclusive about the Reade allegations, was that further
investigation was needed—an investigation put together by the Democratic
Fox News Channel political analyst Britt Hume’s response to
this on Twitter was perfect.
months in which this story has festered, Biden finally commented directly about
the allegations in a May
1 interview on MSNBC’s “Morning Joe” with co-host Mika Brzezinski,
who actually asked some serious and tough questions.
Biden said that Reade’s account “is not true.”
Predictably, many on the left were unhappy even with this
level of questioning.
Maria Cardona, a Democratic strategist, wrote that Reade’s accusations simply have been used by
Republicans to “weaponize the issue” in an effort to delegitimize the #MeToo
The lack of media scrutiny seems all the more inconsistent with evidentiary standards pushed by the left back in 2011 in the context of sexual assault on campus.
At that time, the Obama administration, in an effort
spearheaded by Biden as vice president, issued a “Dear Colleague” letter to
college administrators. In it, the Obama administration directed them to
adjudicate sexual assault cases under Title IX, a provision in federal law that
prohibits discrimination based on sex by institutions receiving financial
assistance. The standard there is “preponderance of evidence” rather than
“clear and convincing evidence.”
As commentator David Harsanyi pointed out on National Review
Online, a college student accused of sexual assault under this standard often was
“denied the ability to question his accuser, denied the right to review the
allegations and evidence in an ensuing investigation, denied the right to
present exculpatory evidence, and denied the right to call witnesses”—and often
while facing adjudication by a single investigator with minimal training.
So a college student can have his life destroyed quickly based
on fairly thin evidence and nothing like the standards of a trial in court, but
a lieutenant governor and a former senator and vice president can just skate on
The message, it seems, is that sexual assault allegations are
supposed to be “weaponized” only against conservatives.
But in the era of “believe all women,” one would think that
at least our putatively nonpartisan press would be quite active in pursuing
what could be a big story.
the media about bringing truth to power or something like that?
It doesn’t take much to see how differently Biden and Fairfax
have been treated by the traditional news media compared to, say, Brett
The standard that the left and so many in the #MeToo movement
set up is that we must simply believe all women, that presumption of
innocence—a cornerstone of American law and concept of justice—is a tool of
This is certainly what was applied to Kavanaugh, a D.C.
Circuit judge whose reputation and nomination to the Supreme Court by President
Donald Trump were nearly destroyed by an accusation of sexual misconduct at a
high school party some 30 years ago. To date, that accusation has gone
uncorroborated by a single witness, or even someone who can confirm that the
party took place.
Although I am not addressing the full merits of any of these
allegations, I note here that the media nevertheless subjected the nation to a
steady barrage of increasingly lurid allegations made against Kavanaugh during
his confirmation hearings, passing them along uncritically on such thin
many of them had to be corrected.
With Fairfax and Biden, mainstream media outlets such as The Washington Post, CNN, and NBC News tread slowly and tepidly to investigate. The common thread is that the mainstream media shirked its duty to seriously investigate the truth about a public figure.
bottom line is, sexual assault allegations should be treated seriously,
especially for men and women in power. However, it undermines the media’s
credibility when they treat such allegations so differently based on what side
of the political spectrum the subject of the allegations is on.
Again, it seems many of these outlets don’t even really try to hide the bias at this point. The only credibility they are concerned with is appealing to predominantly left-wing viewers, colleagues, and institutions while maintaining a thin glaze of “objectivity.”
not inherently wrong. But at the very least, Americans should know what these
media institutions are really about and not be deceived into thinking they are
the only authoritative word on what the truth is.